Our History

The Story of NiMarco’s Pizza

Celebrating 45 Years as Flagstaff’s Hometown Pizzeria

We realize that there are several pizza places to choose from out there. If you’re reading this, it probably means you’re looking for something that surpasses the ordinary. Well, look no more because you are about to embark on one of the best pizza-eating experiences in Flagstaff. There is a reason why NiMarco’s Pizza has been going strong since its doors opened in 1979! We are dedicated to making the best homemade pizza possible. Our dough and sauce are made fresh daily, and our cheese is specially ordered and grated fresh every day. We are committed to using only the freshest, best-tasting ingredients, so as the saying goes, “You get what you pay for!”

3 Convenient Locations in Flagstaff

Our original store is located downtown, just south of the tracks on Beaver Street. Our second location is right at the entrance of NAU on Milton Road as you enter Flagstaff from the south. Our third location is on the eastside of town on the corner of Kaspar Drive and historic Route 66. So, no matter where you are in Flagstaff, you’ll never be too far from some of the tastiest pizza you’ll ever have!

Local Love

We are NAU alumni, residents of Flagstaff, and hands-on operators since 2000. We love our town and we love what we do. From the bottom of our hearts, we thank you for supporting local business and, more importantly, for having such good taste!


Dave, Angie, Tommy & Danny